Meade’s knocked her first aria right out of the park. Beautiful singing, lovely arcs of long long phrases, beautiful soft singing. And she seemed like she knew where she was going whereas Trebs seemed more in a kind of daze.
This was my first Bolena from a side box (balcony, all the way forward on the left); I was surprised how even though so much of the set seemed to have tall walls at angles, there was rarely a time I couldn’t see everything going on. As usual, from the left, sometimes the brass section blasts above the singing, and oftentimes when singers are aimed the other way you can’t hear them; Meade’s laser-voice seems to project omnidirectionally in that it doesn’t really seem to matter where she’s looking, she sounds basically the same. Which allows her the same range of irritating never-facing-the-audience singing that Trebs did, but I think it worked better for her.
Where Meade did know to never face anywhere but at us, was in ensembles. Here, either she can’t sing loud enough, or chooses not to. Either way, disappointing. The crazy highs are maybe 5 times louder than any other part of her voice, and were for the most part great. But in ensemble singing she just never dominated the way I would have liked. Maybe she was trying to be polite and blend with other singings, but she’s the lead and I think she should soar/blast above everyone at all times.
The scene with Percy was one of the best of the first half – I think rather than being deafened by Trebs and knowing he could never sing louder than her, where he held back, here, he and Meade were a much better match volume-wise and I think he brought a lot more passion and ringing volume with Meade. He sounded fantastic! And I find most bel cantoish tenors tend to have the high notes but not a lot else; Costello seems to have a very fine low range that has none of the ugly mush other tenors (*cough* Nabucco tenor) seem to have on the lows.
Where I appreciated Meade’s skills/talents/etc. most was the Act I finale. With Trebs and her darkish mezzoish voice it was hard to distinguish between her and Seymour; but Meade’s clear laser soprano blended and contrasted excellently with Seymour. Her two outburst high notes were there, sure, but they weren’t the explosive bellows from Trebs. The high D started good and only got better. She was facing exactly away from me and her face was practically in Henry’s chest, but oh so loud. And while it started F by the time she screamed her way through however-many bars of music it reached FFF. Good stuff.
Second half was at least twice as good as the first. The duet with Seymour was less angry raging giants battling on stage as it was a brutal vicious soprano attack on the poor sympathetic Seymour. Dramatically, I thought it played better to have Bolena nastier and Seymour actually afraid of being cut. The duet ended on a very nice high note for each and there was none of the usual I-can-hold-it-longer stuff (but note to both, please both hold it longer next time!).
By the way, Meade joins the exclusive club of singers-who-can-sing-tough-notes-while-in-the-act-of-standing-up. And while Kaufman does it so impressively (he did some crazy Vittorias in Tosca that started on the ground and ended with him standing), Meade does it better and with a lot more body to lift. It seemed every five minutes she was on the ground and having to get up from the floor while singing crazy tough stuff. In a way she’s like Natalie Dessay – Dessay can sing anything while being picked up, tossed around, spun, flung in any direction – Meade can sing anything while awkwardly getting up from the floor. Let’s just let her stand some more next time, or her knees will go long before her voice.
The pleading with Henry was kind of boring, as always, but I thought the chemistry with Costello really worked here and vastly improved the scene. Then Seymour came out in crazy good voice (and she was sick the last time I saw this two weeks ago) and sang the shit out of her final scene. She tore out some spectacular notes.
Costello had his big number, and it rocked. He didn’t get nearly enough audience love, because he sure deserved it for singing that crazy evil hard music so so well. What a difference from the opening. And, finally, with these better seats, I could see just how cute he actually is. And he’s 30? I’m surprised Gelb hasn’t cast him in every HD through 2020!
And why is Bolena’s brother not singing Henry? He was crazy loud. Henry was better tonight, possibly my seat, but the brother had gargantuan sound.
And then the endless women’s chorus. Why? It’s so late, everyone wants to leave but has to wait for the mad scene. Anyway, after 10 minutes of chorus torture, the spot came on to Meade kneeling. And, I don’t know who thought it was a good idea to give her that much hair, but the way they spread it over her and the fact that there was so damned much of it made her look like Cousin It. Serious, a giant round ball of draping curly hair. It was fine once she stood up and ponytailed it off, but I almost laughed out loud when I first saw it.
Also, what the hell happened to the costumes? Trebs gets dress after dress, fancy head thing after head thing. Meade gets one dress for Act I and most of Act II, and then basically the same dress + way too much hair for the final scene? I can’t disagree with the wise decision not to put her in a giant red thing for the end of Act I, but they could have tried harder. Mind you, theses are the people who put Trebs, who though now slightly chubby is still a voluptuous and beautiful woman, into fugly dresses that made her look as big as (half-of) a house. Anyways, Meade’s two dresses looked actually pretty flattering on her, so good stuff.
The mad scene was, as with Trebs, the best part of the show. And while Trebs seemed like she sang everything in a form of autopilot until this point but Meade seemed on from the start, Meade certainly turned up the intensity here. I’d choose Trebs just for the beauty of the (sometimes off pitch, smudy runs, etc) sound she makes, but hearing Meade here was a delight. There were some places where I seriously wanted to shout “breathe! You’ll get brain damage if you don’t!” Like entire 30-second phrases. Was I missing tiny silent gulps of air, or does this girl just not need air? It was crazy. There was one part where I think she ran out after singing 3, 4, maybe even 7 phrases in one breath and ended on a very high note starting a new phrase, which I think stopped rather abruptly. Otherwise though, it was an impressive vocal feat, especially after 3 hours of singing already.
And then the cabaletta arrived (love those cannons offstage!) and boy did it slam by at a terrifying pace; cruel conducting, or choice by Meade? I’ve never heard more notes smashed ever so accurately into so short a time. And where Trebs did runs that started high and ended low (and mushed all over the place), Meade did runs that seemed to have zillions more notes and that started high, glissando’d to the bottom, hammered back up, and ended with terrifying drops into scary scary chest. I wouldn’t want to hear one of those lows in a dark alley at night, yikes! And, from the recording I heard of her last week, either she totally rethought what she wanted to sing, or has millions of alternate options in her mind and chooses whatever suits her mind at the exact moment, or maybe, like Dessay, is just making interpolations as she goes. They were really great. And how does she actually hit every not so accurately and have time to sing it before zipping on to the next? Like a vocal machine-gun! And then, the final note was crazy good, different than Trebs’ crazy good note, but equally crazy good. I think in her mind she almost chose to scream it up to the e-flat (she didn’t), but it was long, loud, and very good. Do the e-flat please and somebody record it though, I’d want to hear that. We know she can do it.
Anyway, the clapping was pretty loud when the red shiny curtain fell, but when they sent Meade forth for a solo bow before doing the regular curtain calls, the sound was thunderous. Cheering, clapping, musicians in the pit were stomping, people in family circle were rioting and kicking things. Can’t think of the last time I’ve heard that kind of hysteria; maybe SondRad’s Vissi D’art, certainly Trebs’s poison aria, pretty much any Zajick Aida Judgment Scene, but it was definitely something special. There was a lot of love for Meade in the audience. Seriously, in retrospect, somebody should have poisoned Fleming before one of my Armidas so I could have heard Meade tear that up.
So to sum up, maybe if I could see only one Bolena, I’d choose Trebs, but this was definitely a performance to remember. Meade needs to sing cabalettas, cabalettas, and more cabalettas. As fast as possible. With extra verses and insane interpolations. And now I am very excited to hear her in Ernani, which is basically one long cabaletta-fest.